The Law Office of Irwin Berowitz, 305 Broadway, Suite 601, New York, NY
IMMIGRATION NEWS & RECENTLY WON CASES
You are here: Home / IMMIGRATION NEWS & RECENTLY WON CASES / Cancellation of Removal / Removal Proceedings Terminated; Client Retains Permanent Resident Stat...
Irwin Berowitz
,

Removal Proceedings Terminated; Client Retains Permanent Resident Status

A picture of an immigration form used by an immigration attorney in NYC

William, who was born in Guyana, came to the USA, with his mother, as a permanent resident when he was 14 years old. That was in 2004. Within a few years, William began to have problems both at home and at school in New York City. During a 2008 visit to a friend in Georgia, William was arrested and charged with stealing. He pleaded guilty to a theft offense.

A picture of an immigration form used by an immigration attorney in NYCBack in New York City, William’s difficulties continued. He was convicted of Grand Larceny in the fourth degree, in January of 2009, and sentenced to two years of probation supervision. Because William “forgot” to keep an appointment with his probation officer, he was resentenced to eight months of incarceration. After he had been in jail for six months, ICE Officers picked him up and shipped him off to a detention center in Texas. That was when his mother came to see me.

After I had reviewed the papers that William’s mother had brought with her, I put William’s mother in contact with a top notch criminal defense attorney in Georgia. William’s mother retained this attorney, who, in a matter of weeks, was able to file a motion to vacate William’s conviction. The attorney argued that there had been a procedural error during the course of William’s criminal court proceedings a year earlier. With that conviction vacated, William was able to get a bond from an Immigration Judge in Texas. I then asked the judge in Texas to change venue to New York City. That motion was granted.

The DHS charged William with removability under INA § 237(a)(2)(A)(i), as an alien who, within five years of his admission to the USA, has been convicted of a crime involving turpitude (a “CIMT”). At the first hearing in New York City, I denied the charge. It took the DHS several hearings to produce a complete record of William’s 2009 New York City conviction. When it did, I stated that William’s conviction is not necessarily a CIMT. The judge asked me to submit a brief in 30 days. I did, arguing that, according to the BIA and the Second Circuit, there is a presumption that a larceny offense is categorically a CIMT only if it contains as an element the intent to deprive the victim permanently of what was stolen from him or her. The record of conviction simply did not indicate William’s intention at the time that he took the victim’s property. The DHS attorney did not file a brief in response to mine.

When we returned to Court, the judge terminated proceedings. The DHS attorney preserved the DHS’ appeal rights, but the DHS did not appeal. William and his mother were delighted with the outcome of the case.

About Irwin Berowitz

The Law Office of Irwin Berowitz specializes in providing legal services to immigrants. These services encompass a broad range of areas, from representation before the U.S. Citizenship & Immigration Services or the Immigration Court, to helping the immigrant obtain post-conviction relief. If you want to make sure that your case is properly handled from the very start, contact us immediately for a free in-person consultation so that you can tell us about your case privately and safely. At the time of the free consultation, we will let you know the likely outcome of your case, and what approach and strategy we would pursue to obtain a successful result for you. We will fight to give you peace of mind and to give your case the best possibility for success. To learn more about our practice, feel free to click on the links on this webpage or contact us by telephone or email. Remember, your first meeting with us in our office is free. All names on these posts have been changed to protect the identities of former clients. Any similarity to any one particular case or person(s) is purely coincidental.
/by
You might also like
The immigration law office of Irwin Berowitz handles deportation hearings, permanent residency applications, green card applications and represents clients in Federal immigration court. CLIENT WINS CANCELLATION OF REMOVAL CASE IN IMMIGRATION COURT
An immigration court judge in Federal court, judge for Department of Homeland Security South American Woman Obtains Permanent Resident Status
Stock image of a green card. Permanent Resident card for the u.s.a IMMIGRATION JUDGE GRANTS JAMAICAN MAN'S MOTION TO REOPEN
A picture of an immigration form used by an immigration attorney in NYC Ecuadorian Client Granted Asylum by Immigration Judge
Immigration attorney in NYC After a difficult fight, client becomes a Permanent Resident
A picture of an immigration form used by an immigration attorney in NYC UPDATE ON ICE'S DETENTION AND REMOVAL POLICY
South American Woman Obtains Permanent Resident Status An immigration court judge in Federal court, judge for Department of Homeland Security The immigration law office of Irwin Berowitz handles deportation hearings, permanent residency applications, green card applications and represents clients in Federal immigration court. Client’s Application for Permanent Resident Status Approved at the Last...